SOLD: $75,000 for Beatles 'Butcher'

The controversial album a favorite among collectors

September 21, 2015
By James Massey

NEW YORK, USA - A rare, sealed, 1966 Beatles Yesterday and Today First State Stereo "Butcher Cover" LP (Rated GEM MINT 10 Condition) has fetched $75,000 at Heritage's Music Memorabilia auction over the weekend.
Beatles Record

Why So Much?

In 1966, The Beatles 'Butcher' (album) cover was put out as an early release of "Yesterday and Today." The album immediately drew criticism due to its image of The Beatles covered in raw-meat and baby-doll parts.

There was such an uproar, Sears only had the album out for one-day before pulling it from shelves. Many stores refused carry it all.

This led to the majority of the albums being recalled so a less controversial image (sticker) could be placed over the album cover. The recall, makes original (first-state) versions extremely rare, and copies in excellent condition even rarer.

The Heritage auction listing does an excellent job explaining the albums rarity in greater detail;

"A very limited number of "first state" albums got out and were kept by journalists, radio stations, and record company executives. In 1966, stereo had yet to take over the marketplace (for one thing, they cost more than the mono copies); it has been estimated that mono was produced in a ten to one ration over the stereo version. There were certainly fewer of these that found their way into collections. Again, a much smaller number of these were never removed from their shrink wrap. An infinitesimal number of those still-sealed examples were kept in the beautiful condition of this one."

Overall, rare Beatles items are one of the hottest collectibles in the marketplace today, sometimes fetching staggering amounts.

In March of 2013, a rare copy of The Beatles - Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967), signed by all four band members, sold for $290,500. The sale broke the world record for the most expensive record sold at that time.

Video: The Beatles Butcher back-story, from a 2003 Antiques Roadshow appraisal

Auction Data & Statistics

According to Heritage Auction's online view-counter. There were over 1,100 visits to the listing, with 8 bidders participating in the auction (via Internet/Mail/Phone) In the end, a phone bidder won.

For more information and close-up photos of the album see; Heritage Auctions lot #90114.

Related Beatles Items, Auctions, and Information:


Want to quote us? If you're willing to credit the article to, and install a live-link to the original article, or, you can feel free to quote up to 50 words.

While all other uses are prohibited without prior written permission (from, we are friendly, and often willing accommodate mutually beneficial ideas and collaborations.

Feel free to contact us with any questions and/or comments. More info about is posted below.

*Price is based on foreign (currency) exchange rate at time of sale.
** eBay auction links generally expire within 90 days of auctions end

About is a free website which monitors millions of auction items, to track the top selling (highest bid) items on eBay, and report top sold items from a variety of specialty auction houses worldwide.

Founded in late 2008, by James Massey, the site has quickly became a valued resource for collectors and treasure hunters interested in knowing which rare antiques and vintage collectibles were selling best at auction.

Journalist and reporters from a wide-variety of media outlets, (CBS, AOL News, Inside Source, eBay Radio, Smart Money, and others) have also found to to be an informative and helpful website.