FOUND > Declaration of Independence Fetches $1.5 Million

Tucked away in a Desk Drawer for Generations

Video
The Declaration of Independence discovery story (video) as told by Blanchard’s Auction Service.

Updated November 12, 2017
By Ruthie Bowles, Contributing Author for What Sells Best

POTSDAM, NEW YORK (VIDEO) - A rare 1776 copy of the Declaration of Independence, found in a desk drawer, has fetched $1.5 million at Blanchard’s Auction Service, according to the Watertown Daily Times.

THE STORY

The New York Times reported, the authenticated Declaration document, and related papers, belong to a descendant of early colonial settlers in eastern Long Island.

On July 9th, 1776, John Holt, the Manhattan publisher, lightly edited the Declaration of Independence, and sent out the copies. This newly discovered copy was originally delivered to Colonel David Mulford, who commanded a regiment in East Hampton. The soldier who delivered the Holt Page, along with other documents, penned a note on the package which read “made Bold to Open & Read them.” Due to his death in 1778 from small pox, he never saw the nation gain its independence from Britain.

Holt edited Congress’ original text by adding a New York politicians’ statement, and changing punctuation. Printings of this page were archived at the New York Public Library; the Westchester County Archives in Elmsford, N.Y.; the Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens in San Marino, California; and the Cincinnati Museum Center (which discovered a copy in its collection in 2015). 

The anonymous auction consignor has members of the Gardiner, Mulford, and Buell families in their ancestry. And, besides the Declaration of Independence, the family also held an additional 75 documents, gathered by Blanchard’s for the auction. They estimated the value of those additional items to be $25,000 to $50,000.

Reportedly, Farmers, ministers, whalers, and housewives authored the additional documents, which detail infant deaths,  land and livestock transactions, and Revolutionary troop movements. Some bookplates printed by Paul Revere for the Gardiner patriarchs are also included. A historian from Cambridge, Massachusetts, Keith Arbour, said that “the rediscovered collection contains many mysteries for scholars to solve”, highlighting the value of these historical documents.

WHY IT'S RARE

John Holt published 500 copies of the Declaration. Only four of these original copies survived, or so it was believed, until a fifth copy surfaced in this private collection. This copy of the Declaration of Independence is the only one still in private hands.

RARE TREASURE

Among the rare documents we have tracked, this one is definitely cause for excitement. There is no doubt that the auction competition will be fierce for this nearly one of a kind piece of U.S. history.

Small details make a big difference in the prices of rare documents. If you believe you have found something, you may want to check with the experts found on our appraisals page.

AUCTION INFORMATION

The Declaration of Independence was poignantly auctioned on Veteran’s Day, November 11, 2017, at Blanchard’s Auction Service in Potsdam, New York. The copy sold for $1.5 million, setting a new record for a New York printing of the Declaration. The sale amount far exceeded Blanchard’s estimates of $500,000 to $1 million.

THE 'MOST WATCHED' PAPER COLLECTIBLES ONLINE

See if you can to spot a bargain treasure among the most-watched Paper Collectibles listed on ebay (research prices). Also see; Top 25: Highest Bid Paper Collectibles on ebay, worldwide, right now (links open on ebay).


Tanglefoot 300000588 8 Oz Tangle-Trap® Brush On Sticky Trap Coating

Watchers: 88
Buy It Now: $12.94
Time Left:
12d 19h 5m


Vintage 1934 popular APPALACHIAN HIKING TRAIL map perfect for framing ME, to GA.

Watchers: 68
Buy It Now: $19.95
Time Left:
22d 22h 21m


Vintage 12 pc,(9 Handwritten) Assorted Paper 1830's-1970's Altered Art Craft

Watchers: 57
Buy It Now: $7.95
Time Left:
12d 9h 3m


(171) GANGSTER CAPONE GIN JOINT SPEAKEASY HOUSE RULES PROHIBITION POSTER 11"x17"

Watchers: 39
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
9d 15h 39m


Vintage Paper Music assortment early Altered Art Craft,18 pages

Watchers: 36
Buy It Now: $7.95
Time Left:
12d 8h 31m


(102) GANGSTER AL CAPONE CHICAGO REWARD CRIME BOSS DEPRESSION ERA POSTER 11"x14"

Watchers: 36
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 18h 55m


Vintage Paper assortment French Altered Art Craft,18 pages

Watchers: 34
Buy It Now: $7.95
Time Left:
12d 8h 41m


(175) GANGSTER LUCKY'S SPEAKEASY HOUSE RULES PROHIBITION BAR ROOM POSTER 11"x17"

Watchers: 29
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
19d 21h 44m


** Lot of 29 Diff -- MINT, New Old Stock - 1940's WHISKEY & BOOZE LABELS

Watchers: 29
Buy It Now: $4.44
Time Left:
13d 2h 50m


(355)GANGSTER MURDER INC. ORGANIZED CRIME PROHIBITION MOB NOVELTY POSTER 11"x17"

Watchers: 27
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 19h 2m


Civil War Document 1865 151st Indiana Discharge Miami County Nashville Tennessee

Watchers: 26
Bid Price: $18.50
Time Left:
1d 1h 39m


Large Lot Vintage Ephemera - Postcards Folders Photos Covere Etc. 1900s-1990s

Watchers: 26
Bid Price: $26.00
Time Left:
20h 23m


LOT OF 200 ELEMENTARY SCHOOL LIBRARY CARD CATALOG INDEX CARDS! DEWEY DECIMAL SYS

Watchers: 25
Buy It Now: $9.95
Time Left:
14d 1h 27m


Vintage Victorian Antique Christmas Die-Cut Scrap Of Santa Riding a Donkey *

Watchers: 24
Buy It Now: $215.50
Time Left:
11d 18h 54m


World War II Ration Books 1 - 4! LEATHER HOLDER! STAMPS! APPLICATION! CHICAGO

Watchers: 23
Buy It Now: $139.98
Time Left:
29d 15h 21m


(107) GANGSTER LUCKY LUCIANO NEW YORK MOBSTER WANTED DEPRESSION POSTER 11"x14"

Watchers: 20
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 18h 56m


Vintage Paper Assortment 1890-1970 Altered Art Craft ,22 pages

Watchers: 20
Buy It Now: $7.95
Time Left:
12d 8h 53m


HISTORIC MAP UNITED STATES WOODBRIDGE 1843 VAST MEXICAN TERRITORY TEXAS INDIAN

Watchers: 20
Bid Price: $17.06
Time Left:
2d 1h 34m


(104) GANGSTER BABY FACE NELSON WANTED REWARD DEPRESSION REPRINT 11"X14" POSTER

Watchers: 17
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 18h 55m


Rare Antique Victorian Girls Fan Shape Scrapbook + Vintage German Die Cuts

Watchers: 16
Buy It Now: $199.00
Time Left:
8d 22h 1m


LOT OF 200 LIBRARY CARD CATALOG INDEX CARDS! DEWEY DECIMAL SYSTEM! FROM COLLEGE

Watchers: 16
Buy It Now: $9.95
Time Left:
3d 22h 14m


Library Card Catalog Index Cards Grade School Crafting Altered Art 200 Lot

Watchers: 15
Buy It Now: $22.00
Time Left:
15d 20h 9m


(097) GANGSTER JOHN DILLINGER 10,000 REWARD WANTED FBI CRIME POSTER 11"x14"

Watchers: 14
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 18h 56m


antique Lawyers Law book from Goldfield Nevada Esmeralda county 1910

Watchers: 14
Buy It Now: $21.00
Time Left:
16d 14h 51m


HUGE OLD PAPER EPHEMERA LOT Ads Labels Illustrations Victorian Vintage Scrap Mix

Watchers: 14
Bid Price: $43.99
Time Left:
1d 31m


Vintage Map Scrap assortment early Altered Art Craft,18 pages

Watchers: 14
Buy It Now: $7.95
Time Left:
22d 22h 32m


Rare Victorian Scrap Santa Xmas Witch Halloween 1930's

Watchers: 14
Buy It Now: $5.99
Time Left:
16h 4m


Antique Fortune Telling Cards Madame Lenormand *Very Rare* 33 Tarot Cards VS/B2

Watchers: 13
Buy It Now: $149.99
Time Left:
25d 22h 38m


Large Box Lot Vintage & Collectible Ephemera 16.5 Pounds Mixed Paper

Watchers: 13
Bid Price: $9.99
Time Left:
2d 19h 1m


(103) GANGSTER BONNIE & CLYDE GANG TEXAS REWARD WANTED DEPRESSION POSTER 11"x14"

Watchers: 13
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 18h 56m


Lot of Vintage and Antique Ephemera, Collage, Junk Journal, Paper Stash

Watchers: 13
Buy It Now: $4.50
Time Left:
7d 15h 26m


1888 Billhead from Julius vom Hofe, Manufacturer of Fishing Reels

Watchers: 12
Bid Price: $10.82
Time Left:
2h 1m


1889 Billhead from WM. Mills & Son Manufacturers and Importers of Fishing Tackle

Watchers: 12
Bid Price: $13.50
Time Left:
2h 31m


Box Lot 30 Antique Vintage Paper Books Catalogs Brochures Ephemera No Reserve

Watchers: 12
Bid Price: $14.95
Time Left:
23h 41m


60+ Lot Pieces Vintage Ephemera Paper Pack Variety stamps German Bible Pages

Watchers: 12
Buy It Now: $11.59
Time Left:
21d 19h 12m


TIGER Label old vintage Chinese Hong Kong sign ad paper China antique medicine

Watchers: 12
Buy It Now: $2.99
Time Left:
16h 28m


Vintage , 36 Miniature Assorted Book Pages For Crafting / Altered Art/ Collage

Watchers: 12
Buy It Now: $7.95
Time Left:
10d 21h 33m


Vintage Ephemera Ledger 1870 great calligraphy, perfect to repurpose

Watchers: 12
Buy It Now: $20.00
Time Left:
24d 18h 2m


100 Vintage Library Card Catalog Index cards for Scrapbooking Crafts Ephemera

Watchers: 11
Buy It Now: $3.50
Time Left:
12h 2m


LOT OF 140+ PIECES OF EPHEMERA FROM 1800'S TO 1950'S HUGE VARIETY AMAZING LOT!

Watchers: 11
Bid Price: $23.49
Time Left:
16h 52m


1825 Conditional Pardon Signed Sir Thomas Brisbane NSW Colonial Era Documen U336

Watchers: 11
Buy It Now: $2912.20
Time Left:
16d 2h 10m


Currency Historical Reproductions Lot, 9 sets 58 Different Notes, Antiqued

Watchers: 11
Buy It Now: $24.95
Time Left:
4d 20h 4m


VINTAGE CHRISTMAS ADVENT NATIVITY ANGELS KRUGER WEST GERMANY

Watchers: 11
Buy It Now: $14.99
Time Left:
4d 2h 22m


RARE 1904 CHILDREN'S WEEK CALENDAR FLORAL FAN MONDAY'S CHILD...NURSERY RHYME

Watchers: 11
Buy It Now: $125.00
Time Left:
12d 14h 35m


VINTAGE COFFEE BAG / CAFE PERLA, PONCE PUERTO RICO

Watchers: 11
Buy It Now: $0.99
Time Left:
23d 3h 34m


1879 Billhead from F vom Hofe & Son, Manufacturers of Fishing Reels

Watchers: 11
Bid Price: $21.50
Time Left:
2h 16m


Civil War Document 1864 6th U.S. Cavalry Brandy Station Munroe City Michigan

Watchers: 11
Bid Price: $12.50
Time Left:
1d 1h 35m


Civil War Document 1864 6th U.S. Cavalry Brandy Station Virginia Warren Ohio VTG

Watchers: 11
Bid Price: $15.16
Time Left:
1d 1h 36m


1850s Print of Natives loading Coal onto a US Ship at Kingston Jamaica

Watchers: 10
Buy It Now: $35.99
Time Left:
7d 2h 20m


(099) GANGSTER JOHN DILLINGER 25,000 REWARD WANTED FBI CRIME POSTER 11"x14"

Watchers: 10
Buy It Now: $4.99
Time Left:
10d 18h 56m