FOUND > Attic Baseball Card Fetches $38,000

Rare 19th-century Hall of Famer discovered in attic

Circa 1888 Mickey Welch Baseball Card.

April 26, 2018
By James Massey, What Sells Best News

ONLINE - Heritage Auctions reports, a 19th-century Baseball Card discovered in an attic, has fetched $38,400. However, that's just one part of an amazing story.

THE DISCOVERY

In an article for Forbes, David Seideman reports the card was originally, and unknowingly, discovered in Hartford Connecticut in 1987. That's when a contractor named Bob, found a small wooden box in the attic of a home he had purchased.

Examples of 19th century Baseball Cards on Antiques Roadshow.

After looking through the top layer of cards, the box appeared to be filled with trading cards featuring obscure 19th-century stage stars. Bob didn't think the cards had much value, so he put the box in his basement. Apparently, waiting for a better time to take a second look.



30-years later, he took another look. That's when he found a treasure trove of Baseball Cards had been waiting for him, at the bottom of the box. The cards, all 19th-century players, reportedly had a combined value of $70,000. However, one card in particular stood out.

HALL OF FAMER

The card, an 1888 Mickey Welch was manufactured by the S.F. Hess Tobacco Company, who slipped Baseball Cards into cigarette packs for promotions.

History of Baseball Cards by Silver Jackify.

Michael “Mickey” Welch (1859 – 1941) was the third pitcher in baseball history to reach 300 wins. A feat that led to his induction to the Baseball Hall of Fame.

WHY IT'S RARE

According to Heritage Auctions description, the card (graded SGC 40 VG 3) "is one of less than a handful of known examples" they know of.

COMPARABLE FINDS

While the financial gain isn't as high as some of the recent Baseball Card treasures we’ve tracked. The story is priceless, and it certainly made for a good year for Bob.

Fine details can make a big difference in Baseball Card prices. If you think you've found something special, you should check with several of the experts listed on our free appraisals page.

THE AUCTION

The card was sold as part of Heritage Auctions 2018 April 19-20 Spring Sports Card Catalog Auction as lot #80001. The final sale price after buyer's premium was $38,400.

CARD PRICES

To monitor the real-time price strength of more common cards. Keep an eye on the ongoing highest-bid cards (below) in the Sports Memorabilia category on eBay. To research sold prices for rare or common cards, click here.


BASEBALL CARDS > Antique | Vintage

 

2009 Bowman Chrome Xfractor Mike Trout ROOKIE RC AUTO /225 PSA 10 GEM MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 57m
$20,250.00 with 25 bids


2009 Bowman Chrome Xfractor Mike Trout ROOKIE RC AUTO /225 BGS 9.5 GEM (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 57m
$14,900.00 with 41 bids


2009 Elite Extra Edition Mike Trout ROOKIE RC AUTO /495 #57 BGS 10 BLACK (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 58m
$12,700.00 with 44 bids


2009 Bowman Chrome Draft Mike Trout ROOKIE RC AUTO #BDPP89 BGS 9.5 GEM MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 57m
$6,100.00 with 18 bids


2011 Topps Update Target Red Border Mike Trout ROOKIE RC #US175 BGS 9 MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 8m
$6,100.00 with 20 bids


T206 Sherry Magie Magee Piedmont 150 SGC 20 1.5 " IMPOSSIBLE ERROR CARD "

Time Left: 23h 51m
$5,622.00 with 30 bids


1993 SP Foil #279 Derek Jeter Yankees RC Rookie BGS 9.5 w/ 10 " SUPER HOT CARD "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$5,288.00 with 21 bids


1933 Goudey #181 Babe Ruth New York Yankees HOF PSA 4 VG-EX " Great Investment "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$5,100.00 with 32 bids


2009 Bowman Chrome DPP Mike Trout Rc Auto Xfractor #15/225 SGC 7 NM Rookie

Time Left: 3d 20h 52m
$5,100.00 with 53 bids


1948 Leaf #79 Jackie Robinson Dodgers RC Rookie HOF PSA 4.5 " ICONIC CARD "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$5,000.00 with 30 bids


1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle Yankees RC Rookie HOF PSA 3 " ICONIC CARD "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$4,250.00 with 28 bids


2011 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Bryce Harper ROOKIE AUTO /150 BGS 9.5 (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 2m
$3,559.00 with 21 bids


2018 Topps Dynasty GOLD MIKE TROUT SHOHEI OHTANI Dual Auto Patch Relic 1/1

Time Left: 7d 22h 13m
$3,383.00 with 26 bids


1951 Bowman #305 Willie Mays Giants RC Rookie HOF PSA 5 " LOOKS NICER "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$3,200.00 with 16 bids


1971 Topps Baseball Wax Pack W/“Coin Insert”= “PSA 7”

Time Left: 3d 12h 52m
$3,000.00 with 1 bids


1969 TOPPS ROLLIE FINGERS BURCHART FLOYD PSA 10 RC GEM MINT RARE POP HOF

Time Left: 5d 21h 55m
$2,788.88 with 19 bids


1968 Topps Mickey Mantle Willie Mays Killebrew SUPER STARS #490 PSA 10 (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 19m
$2,775.00 with 24 bids


1954 Topps #128 Henry Hank Aaron Braves RC Rookie HOF PSA 6 " LOOKS NICER "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$2,550.00 with 20 bids


1956 Topps Mickey Mantle #135 PSA 7 NRMT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 20h 58m
$2,550.00 with 16 bids


1968 Topps #177 Nolan Ryan Mets RC Rookie HOF PSA 8 " SHARP CORNERS "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$2,469.00 with 26 bids


2013 Bowman Chrome Aaron Judge /50 Rookie Black Wave Refractor BGS 9.5 Auto 10

Time Left: 5d 22h 35m
$2,325.00 with 13 bids


1958 Topps Mickey Mantle ALL-STAR #487 PSA 9 MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 1m
$2,275.00 with 40 bids


1909 E95 Philadelphia Caramel Honus Wagner PSA 4 VGEX (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 20h 52m
$2,261.00 with 15 bids


1994 Fleer Procards Michael Jordan. 2 Cards

Time Left: 3d 21h 6m
$2,250.00 with 1 bids


1954 TOPPS #128 HANK AARON RC ROOKIE PSA 5 EX HOF - JUST GRADED!!!

Time Left: 21h 52m
$2,205.08 with 27 bids


1955 Topps #164 Roberto Clemente Pirates RC Rookie HOF PSA 6 " PACK FRESH "

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$2,175.00 with 36 bids


2017 Bowman Chrome Auto Rc Rookie Ronald Acuna Jr. Blue Refractor BGS 10 117/150

Time Left: 6d 21h 52m
$2,100.00 with 8 bids


2011 Bowman Platinum Prospects Bryce Harper Gold Refractor Auto 21/50 BGS 9.5 10

Time Left: 6d 22h 37m
$2,100.00 with 1 bids


2011 Topps Update #US175 Mike Trout Angels RC Rookie BGS 10 PRISTINE

Time Left: 3d 23h 51m
$2,077.00 with 7 bids


2011 Topps Update Mike Trout ROOKIE RC #US175 BGS 10 PRISTINE (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 7m
$2,034.00 with 19 bids


# 1989 Upper Deck Baseball Low # Case Sealed Griffey (20 Boxes)

Time Left: 2d 20h 18m
$2,025.00 with 12 bids


1959 Topps Mickey Mantle #10 PSA 8 NM-MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 2m
$2,025.00 with 24 bids


1993 SP Foil Derek Jeter ROOKIE RC #279 PSA 8.5 NM-MT+ 

Time Left: 5d 11h 45m
$2,001.00 with 17 bids


2011 Topps Mike Trout RC #US175 LA Angels BLACK Border 60/60 RARE

Time Left: 5d 9h 38m
$2,000.00 with 19 bids


1993 Topps Finest Refractor #47 Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers PSA 9 MINT

Time Left: 22h 32m
$1,925.00 with 19 bids


2011 Topps Update Cognac Diamond Mike Trout ROOKIE RC #US175 PSA 10 GEM (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 8m
$1,925.00 with 16 bids


2011 Topps Update Wal-Mart Blue Border Mike Trout ROOKIE RC PSA 10 GEM MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 8m
$1,875.00 with 8 bids


1938 Goudey Heads Up #250 Joe DiMaggio Yankees RC Rookie HOF PSA 4 LOOKS NICER

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$1,850.00 with 32 bids


1951 Bowman MICKEY MANTLE #253 PSA Authentic Yankees Rookie RC

Time Left: 23h 9m
$1,825.00 with 17 bids


Ronald Acuna Jr. 2017 1ST Bowman Chrome Gold Shimmer BGS 9.5/10 Auto #4/50

Time Left: 4d 20h 23m
$1,825.00 with 17 bids


1955 Bowman Mickey Mantle #202 PSA 7 NRMT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 20h 55m
$1,825.00 with 15 bids


Mike Trout 2009 Bowman Sterling Rookie Auto BGS Graded 9.5/10

Time Left: 19h 55m
$1,800.00 with 18 bids


2009 Bowman Sterling Prospect Mike Trout ROOKIE PSA/DNA 10 AUTO PSA 10 (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 58m
$1,775.00 with 24 bids


2009 Bowman Sterling Prospect Mike Trout ROOKIE RC AUTO PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 57m
$1,745.00 with 38 bids


2015 Topps Dynasty Roberto Clemente Cut Auto Autograph Duel Game Used Bat 1 /1

Time Left: 6d 19h 52m
$1,734.00 with 28 bids


1952 Topps Set Break #261 - Willie Mays RC PSA 4 VG-EX *GMCARDS*

Time Left: 22h 2m
$1,691.00 with 37 bids


1957 Topps Mickey Mantle #95 PSA 7 NRMT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h
$1,650.00 with 25 bids


1970 Topps SETBREAK Joe Morgan #537 PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 3d 23h 39m
$1,647.22 with 15 bids


1956 Topps SETBREAK Mickey Mantle #135 PSA 7 NRMT (PWCC)

Time Left: 3d 22h 38m
$1,625.00 with 17 bids


VLADIMIR GUERRERO JR. 2016 Bowman Chrome RC AUTO REFRACTOR PSA 10 # 271/499

Time Left: 6d 15h 58m
$1,625.00 with 18 bids


1961 TOPPS COMPLETE SET 587 Cards w/MANTLE EXMT-NRMT BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!

Time Left: 4d 12h 9m
$1,590.68 with 4 bids


# 1989 Upper Deck Baseball High # Case Sealed Griffey (20 Boxes)

Time Left: 1d 20h 18m
$1,570.37 with 25 bids


2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Aaron Judge ROOKIE RC, PSA/DNA 10 AUTO PSA 10 (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 13m
$1,555.00 with 13 bids


2011 Bowman Chrome Refractor #175 Mike Trout Angels RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT

Time Left: 3d 23h 32m
$1,525.00 with 22 bids


2009 Bowman Sterling Prospect Mike Trout ROOKIE RC AUTO PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 58m
$1,525.00 with 22 bids


2011 Topps Update Wal-Mart Blue Border Mike Trout ROOKIE RC PSA 10 GEM MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 8m
$1,525.00 with 6 bids


Babe Ruth 1933 Goudey #53 PSA 1-Graded Collectors Card

Time Left: 3d 14h 37m
$1,516.00 with 30 bids


1956 Topps Baseball #33 Roberto Clemente PSA 8 NM-MT Pittsburgh Pirates

Time Left: 1d 21h 57m
$1,502.00 with 20 bids


T206 Type 2 Joe Dunn Brooklyn " BLANK BACK PROOF " SGC " CRAZY RARE "

Time Left: 23h 51m
$1,475.00 with 18 bids


2009 Bowman Sterling Mike Trout RC Rookie Signed AUTO Angels PSA 10 GEM MINT

Time Left: 3d 23h 51m
$1,475.00 with 16 bids


2013 Topps Update Black Nolan Arenado ROOKIE RC /62 #US259 PSA 10 GEM (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 15m
$1,475.00 with 14 bids


Mike Trout 2009 Bowman Chrome Draft Prospects Angels RC Rookie Signed Auto BGS 9

Time Left: 8d 21h 52m
$1,475.00 with 19 bids


1951 Bowman Set Break #253 Mickey Mantle RC BVG AUTHENTIC ALTERED *GMCARDS*

Time Left: 6d 20h 57m
$1,450.00 with 29 bids


1973 Topps Mike Schmidt ROOKIE RC #615 PSA 9 MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 25m
$1,375.00 with 4 bids


1965 Topps Steve Carlton ROOKIE RC #477 PSA 9 MINT (PWCC-PQ)

Time Left: 6d 21h 15m
$1,325.00 with 16 bids


1970 Topps SETBREAK Nolan Ryan #712 PSA 9 MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 3d 23h 51m
$1,313.00 with 18 bids


1961 Topps Baseball Mid Grade Complete Set (587/587) Mantle, Mays, HI #'s

Time Left: 21h 2m
$1,288.28 with 9 bids


1959 Topps Baseball Mid Grade Complete Set (572/572) *29 PSA Mantle, Mays, Aaron

Time Left: 7d 20h 39m
$1,275.00 with 9 bids


1952 Topps Set Break #312 - Jackie Robinson PSA 4 VG-EX *GMCARDS*

Time Left: 22h 27m
$1,266.00 with 36 bids


1970 Topps SETBREAK Frank Robinson ALL-STAR #463 PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 3d 23h 33m
$1,225.00 with 10 bids


2018 Shohei Ohtani Rookie Autograph Mint 7 Card RC Auto Lot

Time Left: 4d 17h 44m
$1,225.00 with 22 bids


2018 Topps Chrome 83 SHOHEI OHTANI SUPERFRACTOR RC AUTO True 1/1 BGS 9 / 10

Time Left: 7d 22h 14m
$1,225.00 with 23 bids


2018 Bowmans Best Performer ACUNA RC AUTO SUPERFRACTOR TURE 1/1 PSA 10

Time Left: 7d 22h 11m
$1,200.00 with 22 bids


1963 Topps #340 Yogi Berra New York Yankees HOF PSA 8 NM-MT

Time Left: 1d 23h 20m
$1,183.18 with 24 bids


2011 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Francisco Lindor Indians RC AUTO /150 BGS 9.5

Time Left: 2d 23h 51m
$1,175.00 with 26 bids


2011 Bowman Draft Gold Mike Trout ROOKIE RC #101 PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 22h 3m
$1,175.00 with 17 bids


2018 Topps Dynasty AARON JUDGE SILHOUETTED MLB LOGO Patch AUTO #ed 1/1 PSA 10

Time Left: 7d 22h 7m
$1,126.00 with 19 bids


1957 Topps Set Break # 95 Mickey Mantle EX-EXMINT *GMCARDS*

Time Left: 19h 14m
$1,125.00 with 43 bids


1954 Topps #128 Henry Aaron PSA 5 EX Rookie RC HOF

Time Left: 2d 11h 37m
$1,125.00 with 16 bids


1949 BOWMAN BASEBALL PARTIAL SET 190/240 EX W/STARS *157864

Time Left: 16h 28m
$1,102.77 with 17 bids


LUKA DONCIC 2018/19 PANINI PRIZM BLUE ICE #280 MAVERICKS ROOKIE RC PSA 10 GEM

Time Left: 1d 22h 26m
$1,100.00 with 7 bids


1954 Topps Henry Hank Aaron PSA 4 RC #128 Braves Beautiful Color!

Time Left: 3d 23h 5m
$1,100.00 with 18 bids


1954 TOPPS HANK AARON HENRY AARON #128 VG+ PSA 3.5 ROOKIE CARD RC

Time Left: 22h 58m
$1,090.00 with 27 bids


1993 SP Foil Derek Jeter ROOKIE RC #279 BGS 9 MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 48m
$1,070.00 with 18 bids


1968 Topps Nolan Ryan Mets Rookies #177 PSA 7 NM Newly Graded Encased

Time Left: 1d 20h 54m
$1,040.00 with 23 bids


1909 E95 Philadelphia Caramel Honus Wagner CGC 1.5 - VG/EX

Time Left: 2d 2h 43m
$1,030.50 with 27 bids


1951 Bowman #165 Ted Williams PSA NM-MT 8

Time Left: 5d 15h 43m
$1,025.00 with 13 bids


1948 Leaf Stan Musial ROOKIE RC #4 PSA 6 EXMT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 20h 52m
$1,025.00 with 13 bids


1958 Topps Mickey Mantle #150 PSA 7 NRMT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 1m
$1,025.00 with 20 bids


1964 Topps Mickey Mantle #50 PSA 8 NM-MT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 12m
$1,025.00 with 24 bids


1980 Topps Nolan Ryan #580 PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 32m
$1,025.00 with 14 bids


1967 TOPPS SEAVER (HOFer) -DENEHY ROOKIES HIGH #581 PSA 7 NM METS

Time Left: 2d 20h 13m
$999.99 with 1 bids


1993 Upper Deck SP Baseball Card #273 DEREK JETER Rookie PSA 10 Auto

Time Left: 1d 22h 9m
$990.00 with 14 bids


1954 Topps #128 Henry Hank Aaron Milwaukee Braves RC Rookie HOF PSA 4 VG-EX

Time Left: 1d 21h 17m
$988.00 with 31 bids


1993 SP Foil Derek Jeter ROOKIE RC #279 SGC 9 MINT (PWCC)

Time Left: 6d 21h 49m
$960.00 with 12 bids


1955 Topps #164 Roberto Clemente PSA 5 EX Rookie RC HOF

Time Left: 2d 11h 37m
$955.65 with 36 bids


TONY LAZZERI 04 UD LEGENDARY CUTS CUT AUTOGRAPH /5 YANKEES AUTO HOF RARE #'d 4/5

Time Left: 2d 7h 50m
$952.00 with 15 bids


2019 Topps Gypsy Queen Baseball 10 Box Factory Sealed Hobby Case

Time Left: 2d 19h 52m
$939.99 with 1 bids


MIKE TROUT SHOHEI OHTANI /25 DUAL AUTO SP 2019 TOPPS HERITAGE REAL ONE AUTOGRAPH

Time Left: 6d 23h 46m
$910.00 with 22 bids


1951 BOWMAN BASEBALL PARTIAL SET 296/324 EX W/STARS *157867

Time Left: 1d 12h 37m
$905.00 with 13 bids